Start here to find
Christmas Cookie Recipes

Home > Recipes > Top 25

Top 25 Christmas Cookie Recipes

Here are the very best recipes at Christmas-Cookies.com, based on reader reviews.

1. 
   Fantasy Fudge
   Yes, this is the original Fantasy Fudge recipe from the back of the Kraft Marshmallow Creme jar. We'll never know why they changed the recipe on us,... more >> about Fantasy Fudge
   5 stars
   Read reviews of fantasy-fudge
2. 
   Seven Layer Magic Bars
   5 stars
   Read reviews of seven-layer-magic-bars
3. 
   Laura Bush’s Cowboy Cookies
   Chewy, monster-sized oatmeal cookies stuffed with nuts and chocolate chips, enhanced with a hint of... more >> about Laura Bush’s Cowboy Cookies
   5 stars
   Read reviews of laura-bush%26rsquo%3Bs-cowboy-cookies
4. 
   Snickers Cookies
   5 stars
   Read reviews of snickers-cookies
5. 
   Potato Candy
   5 stars
   Read reviews of potato-candy
6. 
   Rosettes
   5 stars
   Read reviews of rosettes
7. 
   Aunt Jackie's Pecan Tarts
   5 stars
   Read reviews of aunt-jackies-pecan-tarts
8. 
   Cream Wafers
   5 stars
   Read reviews of cream-wafers
9. 
   Pumpkin Roll
   Pumpkin and spice flavored roll cake with a cream cheese... more >> about Pumpkin Roll
   5 stars
   Read reviews of pumpkin-roll
10. 
    Muddy Buddies
    A college party staple...Chex cereal mixed with chocolate and peanut butter. Also affectionately known as Puppy Chow. Serves about 12... more >> about Muddy Buddies
    5 stars
    Read reviews of muddy-buddies
11. 
    Pistachio Christmas Ribbon Bars
    A festive bar with a shortbread crust, red jam filling and a crumble topping scattered with chopped... more >> about Pistachio Christmas Ribbon Bars
    5 stars
    Read reviews of pistachio-christmas-ribbon-bars
12.  
    Minnesota Munchers
    5 stars
    Read reviews of minnesota-munchers
13. 
    Thumbprint Cookies
    Filled with jam and rolled in chopped nuts, these thumbprints are easy, delicious and very... more >> about Thumbprint Cookies
    5 stars
    Read reviews of thumbprint-cookies
14.  
    No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars
    5 stars
    Read reviews of no-bake-chocolate-peanut-butter-bars
15. 
    Oatmeal Raisin Spice Cookies in a Jar
    5 stars
    Read reviews of oatmeal-raisin-spice-cookies-in-a-jar
16.  
    Galettes
    These cookies are made with a special galette iron. If you don't have one, try a pizzelle iron. One reader tells us that even a waffle iron works... more >> about Galettes
    5 stars
    Read reviews of galettes
17. 
    Salt Dough Ornaments
    If you are looking for some fun and inexpensive crafts to do this Christmas, making ornaments with salt dough is a good choice. Basically, with... more >> about Salt Dough Ornaments
    5 stars
    Read reviews of salt-dough-ornaments
18.  
    Blockbuster Brownies
    5 stars
    Read reviews of blockbuster-brownies
19. 
    Eggnog Kringla
    5 stars
    Read reviews of eggnog-kringla
20.  
    Nutmeg Logs
    5 stars
    Read reviews of nutmeg-logs
21.  
    Caramel Candy Bars
    5 stars
    Read reviews of caramel-candy-bars
22. 
    Candy Cane Crisps
    5 stars
    Read reviews of candy-cane-crisps
23.  
    BonBon Cookies
    Round cookies with maraschino cherry in the center and an almond... more >> about BonBon Cookies
    5 stars
    Read reviews of bonbon-cookies
24. 
    Judy's Nut Ball Cookies
    5 stars
    Read reviews of judys-nut-ball-cookies
25. 
    Napoleon Creams
    Canadians know these as Nanaimo Bars. The difference is that the Original... more >> about Napoleon Creams
    5 stars
    Read reviews of napoleon-creams